No booking fees. Prices include VAT

Guest reviews - Edinburgh hotels

Guest reviews are another great way to browse and select a hotel. On this page we present only the best reviewed hotels - with scores of 80% or greater. To stay up to date, our review percentages are the average of the most recent 100 guest scores.

The Scotsman

The Scotsman

5 star

100%

Royal Mile - Old Town. -

Room Only
from £125

"Great hotel"(20/2/2011)

"We were treated like royalty. We liked ..."(9/12/2010)

EXCEPTIONAL, 100%. Score from 5 Guest Reviews

Knight Residence

Knight Residence

5 star

98%

Old town.Central 5* luxury apart-hotel

Bed & Breakfast
from £92

"Great value for money - exactly what we ..."(29/11/2011)

"Everything was perfect"(27/11/2011)

"Fantastic"(2/5/2011)

EXCEPTIONAL, 98%. Score from 24 Guest Reviews

Glasshouse Edinburgh

Glasshouse Edinburgh

5 star

97%

Central Edinburgh. Near Edinburgh Playhouse Theatre

Room Only
from £108

"Excellent!!!!"(3/5/2011)

"we thoroughly enjoyed our stay, excellen..."(18/2/2011)

"A very smart home from home in the city ..."(31/1/2011)

EXCEPTIONAL, 97%. Score from 5 Guest Reviews

Balmoral Hotel

Balmoral Hotel

5 star

97%

Princes St - New Town. Near Princes Mall

Room Only
from £150

"Lovely Birthday surprise"(30/1/2012)

"40th birthday treat"(30/11/2011)

"Excellent Hotel and perfect Location"(11/6/2011)

EXCEPTIONAL, 97%. Score from 6 Guest Reviews

Holyrood Apts

Holyrood Apts

4 star+

96%

Holyrood. Stylish 4* Deluxe ApartHotel

Bed & Breakfast
from £80

"Ideal location, all the facilities you n..."(26/10/2011)

"Great location, immaculate, comfortable ..."(25/5/2010)

"Immaculate"(25/3/2010)

EXCEPTIONAL, 96%. Score from 22 Guest Reviews

Macdonald Holyrood

Macdonald Holyrood

4 star

95%

Royal Mile - Old Town. Near Our Dynamic Earth

Room Only
from £71

"wonderful hotel friendly staff"(10/8/2011)

"excellent standard of accommodation and ..."(7/2/2011)

"Well looked after"(30/8/2010)

EXCEPTIONAL, 95%. Score from 10 Guest Reviews

Bonham

Bonham

4 star

95%

Princes St - New Town. -

Room Only
from £97

"good features; friendly helpful staff; j..."(24/1/2011)

"Everything first class"(21/12/2010)

"amazing hotel - just like home!"(28/9/2010)

EXCEPTIONAL, 95%. Score from 10 Guest Reviews

The Howard

The Howard

5 star

95%

New Town.Intimate 5* luxury 10 minutes from princes Street.

Bed & Breakfast
from £99

"Great Hotel"(27/1/2012)

"Exceeded expectations. Staff exceptional..."(25/1/2012)

"The staff were exceptional and the servi..."(12/12/2011)

EXCEPTIONAL, 95%. Score from 9 Guest Reviews

Channings Hotel

Channings Hotel

4 star

94%

Edinburgh Castle. Near Dean Gallery

Bed & Breakfast
from £69

"Comfortable and well managed"(30/1/2012)

"A very efficient and helpful welcome; go..."(26/12/2011)

"Lovely hotel in quiet area."(19/5/2011)

SUPERB, 94%. Score from 10 Guest Reviews

Salisbury Green

Salisbury Green

3 star

92%

Edinburgh Castle. Near National Library of Scotland

Room Only
from £74

"great for a weekend of discovering!"(28/11/2011)

"Great accommodation set away from the no..."(25/9/2011)

SUPERB, 92%. Score from 8 Guest Reviews

Edinburgh Waterfront

Edinburgh Waterfront

4 star

91%

Leith. Near Royal Yacht Britannia

Room Only
from £64

"Friendly staff and good bus link to city..."(5/2/2012)

"Excellent accommodation."(1/2/2012)

"Comfortable, clean and exceptional value..."(15/1/2012)

SUPERB, 91%. Score from 7 Guest Reviews

Radisson Edinburgh

Radisson Edinburgh

4 star+

91%

Royal Mile. Central 4* deluxe with leisure facilities

Room Only
from £95

"Great location, helpful staff. Very clea..."(21/12/2011)

"Staff were pleasant and helpful. We enjo..."(12/12/2011)

"One of the nicest hotels I`ve stayed in ..."(7/11/2011)

SUPERB, 91%. Score from 328 Guest Reviews

The George

The George

4 star+

89%

New Town Stunning hotel close to Princes Street

Room Only
from £69

"Very enjoyable stay had a lovely time."(27/12/2011)

"Brilliant"(25/12/2011)

"enjoyable stay. staff welcoming and help..."(26/11/2011)

EXCELLENT, 89%. Score from 189 Guest Reviews

Old Waverley

Old Waverley

3 star

88%

Princes Street . Fine 3* in the heart of the city

Bed & Breakfast
from £50

"Stayed There for Years...whenever in Edi..."(25/1/2012)

"GREAT LOCATION"(23/12/2011)

"gerry a excellent barman and member of s..."(27/11/2011)

EXCELLENT, 88%. Score from 734 Guest Reviews

Minto Hotel

Minto Hotel

3 star

88%

Royal Mile - Old Town. Near National Library of Scotland

Room Only
from £49

"the hotel is very clean, high standards ..."(5/1/2012)

"I found every member of staff very polit..."(25/7/2011)

"Good service, excellent breakfast, helpf..."(1/3/2011)

EXCELLENT, 88%. Score from 19 Guest Reviews

Jurys Inn Edinburgh

Jurys Inn Edinburgh

3 star

87%

Royal Mile/Old Town. Heart of Edinburgh near Edinburgh Castle

Room Only
from £50

"Excellent reception and superb room"(7/12/2011)

"Perfect!"(25/10/2011)

"excellent"(18/9/2011)

EXCELLENT, 87%. Score from 42 Guest Reviews

Ocean Apartments

Ocean Apartments

3 star

86%

Leith. Fully furnished modern apartments.

Room Only
from £72

"Great accommodation"(9/9/2010)

"--"(25/5/2010)

"WELL KEPT, CLEAN. QUIET, WELL PRICED, WI..."(27/3/2010)

EXCELLENT, 86%. Score from 9 Guest Reviews

Macdonald Roxburghe

Macdonald Roxburghe

4 star

86%

Princes St - New Town. Near Charlotte Square

Room Only
from £72

"First class accomodation !"(5/12/2011)

"Lovely room in a lovely location. Also v..."(1/11/2010)

EXCELLENT, 86%. Score from 10 Guest Reviews

Apex Waterloo Place

Apex Waterloo Place

4 star

85%

Princes Street. Contemporary 4* with leisure facilities.

Room Only
from £90

"very comfortable and very attentive staf..."(23/8/2011)

"Excellent hotel in a perfect position fo..."(3/4/2011)

"Excellent location, friendly helpful sta..."(25/10/2010)

EXCELLENT, 85%. Score from 6 Guest Reviews

King James

King James

4 star

85%

Princes Street. Great 4* just off Princes street

Room Only
from £44

"Very friendly staff. Great value for mon..."(30/1/2012)

"Great hotel, great location, next to Pla..."(22/1/2012)

"Very comfy stay,helpful staff"(17/1/2012)

EXCELLENT, 85%. Score from 251 Guest Reviews

Murrayfield Hotel

Murrayfield Hotel

Budget

84%

Murrayfield. Perfectly placed for arriving by air

Bed & Breakfast
from £52

"Felt very welcome"(19/12/2008)

"Breakfast was the best."(25/10/2007)

VERY GOOD, 84%. Score from 34 Guest Reviews

Carlton Hotel

Carlton Hotel

4 star

82%

Royal Mile. Classic 4* just off the Royal Mile

Bed & Breakfast
from £70

"Perfectly located, beautifully presented..."(12/12/2011)

"Noise from Street"(5/12/2011)

"Reception/ Front of house staff fantasti..."(14/11/2011)

VERY GOOD, 82%. Score from 308 Guest Reviews

Bank Hotel

Bank Hotel

3 star

80%

Old Town.Rooms inspired by famous Scots

Room Only
from £77

"Great location. Excellent breakfast."(28/4/2009)

"Personal service"(3/3/2009)

"Extremely happy . Very clean. Friendly..."(8/9/2008)

VERY GOOD, 80%. Score from 21 Guest Reviews

Our review system

Guest reviews are sent to Hotel Direct by guests immediately after check-out. They are un-edited.

Narrow results

Location

Show more locations

Show fewer locations

Facilities